G'day Punter!

Sign In Register

In this Discussion

Who's Online

0 Members & 3 Non Members

Inaccurate Race Call

West Australian Racing
SLIPPERGOLDENSLIPPERGOLDEN    8,448 posts
edited December 2013 West Australian Racing
Last race yesterday was very ordinary. Darren Mac calls the official third horse finishing 6th. Not for the first time the leading group are well past the post by the time he calls the third and fourth incorrectly. Yes a big moment for trainer Wilson landing a winner on his 78th birthday but surely the priority is to call the finish particularly the first four over the line as accurately as possible. If other comments on things such as birthdays are required then surely at the end of the call is a more appropriate time to do so.
+1 -1

[DeletedUser], RoisinDubh, TheFunkster, Forelock, RIO, discostewz, Darkhorse, tony, Rodent, oldhendo, AceV likes this post.

Theodor, whitewash, AndrewCarter, SPUDLEY, thefalcon, Piston_Broke dislikes this post.

Comments

  • rooboyrooboy    1,444 posts
    Great Post Slip! I could name you 100's of calls that he does'nt know who ran 3rd etc etc!Clearly a horse was 1/2 lgth 3rd and he has'nt got the balls to call it!

    houdini65, Darkhorse, AceV likes this post.

    SPUDLEY, Theodor dislikes this post.

    +1 -1
  • DamienWyerDamienWyer    7,982 posts
    Race 3

    "coming around the turn, 350M to go and Sonny Biscay shook them off and raced away, it's Sonny Biscay in full flight, led by three .................. "

    I was listening in the carpark whilst waiting for Sam to arrive. I laughed when Sonny Biscay only managed to run fourth.

    [DeletedUser] likes this post.

    Theodor, rick dislikes this post.

    +1 -1
  • therealkramertherealkramer    8,008 posts
    I hear Hilton Donaldson might be looking for a job :)]

    paraletic likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • Piston_BrokePiston_Broke    2,047 posts
    Damien Wyer said:

    Race 3

    "coming around the turn, 350M to go and Sonny Biscay shook them off and raced away, it's Sonny Biscay in full flight, led by three .................. "

    I was listening in the carpark whilst waiting for Sam to arrive. I laughed when Sonny Biscay only managed to run fourth.

    Seriously that comment shows your lack of knowledge when it comes to racing, You have absolutely no idea watch the replay Damo...... "coming around the turn, 350M to go and Sonny Biscay shook them off and raced away, it's Sonny Biscay in full flight, led by three .................. "

    thefalcon, Theodor, RoisinDubh likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • Piston_BrokePiston_Broke    2,047 posts
    Fourwhitesocks said:

    What about the other week when he declared Darlington Abbey the winner on the corner... All because it was S.Miller and D.Whyte... Needless to say it ran last...

    I must have listened to another race "Now Dougie Whyte pulls Darlington Abbey to the outside with a run"  just how is that declaring D A the winner Socks?


    Seriously if you want to pot a someone 4whitesocks at least give yourself a chance not to look silly

    thefalcon, Jordan, jazza, whitewash, Theodor likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • jaysonjayson    105 posts
    Not the easiest job around, add to that you have to make the call interesting... i doubt anyone has gone through their race calling career without a mistake or miss judgement! .

    thefalcon, therealkramer, SPUDLEY, AndrewCarter, Piston_Broke, whitewash, Theodor, Chelsea likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • thefalconthefalcon    20,474 posts

    you guys trot this thread out everytime the guy makes a perceived blue.

    its a taxing job...if you reckon you can do better...learn his trade...

    X(

    therealkramer, whitewash, Theodor, scoot likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • thefalconthefalcon    20,474 posts
    did he rave about SM when he came out and won the last 3 races a week later..i think not, just said it was a great achievement, or words to that effect, which it was. :-?
    +1 -1
  • Piston_BrokePiston_Broke    2,047 posts
    declared Darlington Abbey the winner on the corner.. is what you said Socks...he never did anything of the kind, if anyone is overemphasizing anything its you ;)

    thefalcon, Jordan, whitewash, Theodor, Chelsea likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • AmyquilAmyquil    250 posts
    edited December 2013
    the falcon said:

    you guys trot this thread out everytime the guy makes a perceived blue.

    its a taxing job...if you reckon you can do better...learn his trade...

    X(


    Whenever someone criticises the race callers you can rely on someone, usually Wes, to say "if you think you can do better...."

    So, should you never criticise a surgeon when they butcher your operation? Will someone then say "you have a go. See if you can do better".

    Most of us aren't race callers. He is; we are entitled to expect excellence. He is the premier caller in a population of two million people.

    I agree with Slip rather than the other comments. If you are listening only and have novelty bets don't rip up your tickets.

    brady, Darkhorse, AceV likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • therealkramertherealkramer    8,008 posts
    Amyquil said:

    the falcon said:

    you guys trot this thread out everytime the guy makes a perceived blue.

    its a taxing job...if you reckon you can do better...learn his trade...

    X(


    Whenever someone criticises the race callers you can rely on someone, usually Wes, to say "if you think you can do better...."

    So, should you never criticise a surgeon when they butcher your operation? Will someone then say "you have a go. See if you can do better".

    Most of us aren't race callers. He is; we are entitled to expect excellence. He is the premier caller in a population of two million people.

    I agree with Slip rather than the other comments. If you are listening only and have novelty bets don't rip up your tickets.

    There is definitely an agenda on here though by some who take any chance to bag DM. In saying that race calling has historically been a job for life and that encourages complacency. We are entitled to expect the best person for the job is in fact doing the job, not waiting for their turn.
    +1 -1
  • thefalconthefalcon    20,474 posts
    to compare a racecaller to a  surgeon is utter stupidity.

    Jordan, JayJay, whitewash, Theodor likes this post.

    AceV dislikes this post.

    +1 -1
  • RIORIO    14,902 posts
    the falcon said:

    to compare a racecaller to a  surgeon is utter stupidity.

    two people trained to do a job, that they get paid for...they are exactly the same in my eyes.

    Fastmoney, Darkhorse likes this post.

    thefalcon dislikes this post.

    +1 -1
  • SLIPPERGOLDENSLIPPERGOLDEN    8,448 posts
    the falcon said:

    you guys trot this thread out everytime the guy makes a perceived blue.

    its a taxing job...if you reckon you can do better...learn his trade...

    X(
    Firstly Amyquil is correct this is not about 'if you reckon you can do a better job'. We all appreciate it can be a taxing job.

    Secondly your comment re the thread is not true Falcon if it was then there would be a lot more previous comments on the forum. We all know callers will make mistakes and if they gets it wrong in a tight finish or a blanket finish yes naturally you can understand it.

    The point I make is that his error is because he has focused on the birthday comment and by the time he gets back to the finish (when they are approx 200 metres past the post) he has not called it accurately... taking his eye of the ball so to speak. This is not the first time this has happened.

    As previously mentioned.. after the call is the time to mention birthday connections etc if need be. Obviously it is different for callers today because they don't have the extended time to spruik after a race as the next brick in the wall to wall racing is about to get under way. Is this the the reason that Daz Mac throws in these comments as horses cross the line?

    For those that oppose my view on this occasion I recommend you have another look at the replay and remember the call is for Australia and at times Asia and there would be many that would not be happy with a third horse being called sixth due to a birthday announcement.

    Whether it is Darren or any other caller... if a racecaller wishes to spruik that's fine but please prioritise calling at least the first four home as accurately as possible.

    TheFunkster, Darkhorse, AceV, Toby likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • therealkramertherealkramer    8,008 posts
    In light of the sudden injection of pace into staying races after criticism on PTT, stand by for ALL horses called in finishing order, as well as the horses scratched on race day, those that didn't accept =))
    +1 -1
  • AmyquilAmyquil    250 posts
    edited December 2013
    the falcon said:

    to compare a racecaller to a  surgeon is utter stupidity.



    Well I have as much chance of getting a race call right as I do of successfully removing your haemorrhoids.

    Why can't they be compared? They are a specialist skill, and I can't do either of them.

    Apparently your Dad was a caller. Are you telling me that what he did could be easily done? Just give it a go? I don't think so.

    Darren has talent but he gets distracted. Whether it's Mr Wilson's 78th or Amelia Park or congratulating Wes for tipping the roughie or plugging some stallion, it all gets in the way of punters getting correct information.

    If you can't deliver that to the best of your ability, why are you there?

    Don't think I've heard Mark Shean go down that road once.

    Darkhorse, AceV likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • Piston_BrokePiston_Broke    2,047 posts
    If you are watching a race the last thing you should be doing is listening to the caller, if you cant see where and how your horse is going, what the hell are you doing punting?

    Listening on the radio is entirely different, its then you need him to give u a description of what is going on in the race, whether he calls 3rd place wrong is not going to change the true result, all in all Macca is the very best in WA and will be for some time yet

    whitewash, Theodor, thefalcon, Chelsea likes this post.

    SLIPPERGOLDEN, Darkhorse, hash dislikes this post.

    +1 -1
  • careycarey    6,424 posts
    "Well I have as much chance of getting a race call right as I do of successfully removing your haemorrhoids."

    11 out of 10 =)) =))

    HenleyBrook likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • AmyquilAmyquil    250 posts
    Piston_Broke said:

    ..........all in all Macca is the very best in WA and will be for some time yet



    Wouldn't argue with that.
    +1 -1
  • therealkramertherealkramer    8,008 posts
    edited December 2013
    Amyquil said:

    Piston_Broke said:

    ..........all in all Macca is the very best in WA and will be for some time yet






    Would love to see Punting Patto have a go. Falcon might even get a shout out after the race.
    +1 -1
  • AmyquilAmyquil    250 posts
    edited December 2013
    Piston_Broke said:


    ....Listening on the radio is entirely different, its then you need him to give u a description of what is going on in the race, whether he calls 3rd place wrong is not going to change the true result.....


    People do listen in on the radio and through apps and on their small smart phone screens.

    They need the picture painted and they're entitled to it.

    Unlike some other city tracks we have one caller per race, all punters/connections/fans/staff in RR studio etc need to be considered.

    Darkhorse likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • DamienWyerDamienWyer    7,982 posts
    Piston_Broke said:

    Damien Wyer said:

    Race 3

    "coming around the turn, 350M to go and Sonny Biscay shook them off and raced away, it's Sonny Biscay in full flight, led by three .................. "

    I was listening in the carpark whilst waiting for Sam to arrive. I laughed when Sonny Biscay only managed to run fourth.

    Seriously that comment shows your lack of knowledge when it comes to racing, You have absolutely no idea watch the replay Damo...... "coming around the turn, 350M to go and Sonny Biscay shook them off and raced away, it's Sonny Biscay in full flight, led by three .................. "
    How does a direct quote from the caller illustrate my lack of Racing knowledge ? These are his words, not mine.


    +1 -1
  • Piston_BrokePiston_Broke    2,047 posts
    and his words were spot on accurate, what was so laughable? 
    +1 -1
  • TheodorTheodor    199 posts
    I want to know who shot Sonny Biscay? Macca's call was spot on. At the 350m mark it took off but completely imploded 100m further on. Damian you do a good job of making yourself out as a goose. No one else needs to help.
    +1 -1
  • TheodorTheodor    199 posts
    Macca is an outstanding caller IMO. I reckon the Wilson family will long remember the call well after all the small minded people forget who came 3rd or 4th. Macca helped make it a special moment!

    Piston_Broke, thefalcon, rick, Chelsea likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • SLIPPERGOLDENSLIPPERGOLDEN    8,448 posts
    edited December 2013
    Piston_Broke said:

    If you are watching a race the last thing you should be doing is listening to the caller, if you cant see where and how your horse is going, what the hell are you doing punting?


    Listening on the radio is entirely different, its then you need him to give u a description of what is going on in the race, whether he calls 3rd place wrong is not going to change the true result, all in all Macca is the very best in WA and will be for some time yet
    That response is ridiculous Piston. So it makes no difference how a race is called because it is not going to change the true result. How about we forget about racecallers and just post the correct results after the race?

    Your last line is a totally different debate and not the topic intention of my original post.

    rooboy, Darkhorse likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • SLIPPERGOLDENSLIPPERGOLDEN    8,448 posts
    Theodor said:

    Macca is an outstanding caller IMO. I reckon the Wilson family will long remember the call well after all the small minded people forget who came 3rd or 4th. Macca helped make it a special moment!

    With all due respect Theodor it was the caller that made it a special moment who forgot who finished third and fourth

    Darkhorse, AceV likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • RIORIO    14,902 posts
    don't give theo any respect he isn't due slip......so many people at the club voted theo on as he was seen as a good young man that wanted to take the club forward, and to dismantle the old boys club...his response of saying mentioning someones birthday is more important than getting the race call correct, is proof that he isn't about to show the punters or owners any respect...so if it is good for him to show such a lack of respect, then treat him exactly the same way.....

    oh and theo is macca paid to call races or send out cheerios???

    SLIPPERGOLDEN, Darkhorse, AceV likes this post.

    thefalcon dislikes this post.

    +1 -1
  • youknowityouknowit    271 posts
    THEODOR PLEASE. DMAC IS AN OUTSTANDING CALLER? AND I SUPPOSE THE FACILITIES AT PERTH RACING VENUES ARE ALSO OUTSTANDING? BOTH ARE JUST OK.

    RIO, SLIPPERGOLDEN, Darkhorse likes this post.

    +1 -1
  • DamienWyerDamienWyer    7,982 posts
    edited December 2013
    Theodor said:

    I want to know who shot Sonny Biscay? Macca's call was spot on. At the 350m mark it took off but completely imploded 100m further on. Damian you do a good job of making yourself out as a goose. No one else needs to help.

    Eddie I haven't seen you in person for many months, yet on Saturday when I decided in the heat not to stand on a ladder promoting Racing via my photography, and take up the invitation to come to lunch with my clients, and they by chance decided to sit in the same row as you to watch their mare race, you decided to brush me. You made eye contact but you are so spineless you just ignored me.

    So what sort of a small minded human being are you mate ? You are so over qualified to be a member of the Perth Racing Committee it is not funny.

    Your chances of selling me a horse are as close to zero as humanely possible.

    SLIPPERGOLDEN, AceV likes this post.

    +1 -1
Sign In or Register to comment.