G'day Punter!

Sign In Register

In this Discussion

Who's Online

0 Members & 43 Non Members

AFL 2017 - Round 18

Sport

Comments

  • detonatordetonator    4,397 posts
    edited July 2017
    dungy said:

    detonator said:

    dungy said:

    Markovina said:

    For mine the Brownlow is overated - and Priddis is an average player at best

    Not an Eagles supporter - but when they had that famed centreline of Mainwaring Kemp and Matera - well Priddis doesnt belong in that company - cant kick over a jam tin

    Is he as good as Chris Lewis - i dont think he is is - what about Brett Heady - id have Heady every day of the week ahead of Priddis ,

    When Bartel won his Brownlow in 2007 - he didnt win the Geelong Best and Fairest that year  - Ablett streeted it in . Bartel was a good player - but wasnt in the same league as Ablett

    The Brownlow at the moment is just a midfielders award - just like it was a ruckmans award in the 70s - Len Thompson - Gary Dempsey - Graham Moss - Barry Round - Graham Teasedale

    The best player  of the last 40 years by the length of the Randwick straight  Wayne Carey ( who got ordinary Nth Melb teams a couple of flags) didnt win a Brownlow - that sums up the Brownlow




    Good post but be careful you have just killed
    Bambi by stating Priddis is just average I've been saying that for a long time and all you get is tears lol lol

    Leave Bambi alone. He was a great player who sadly has come to the end of his playing days.
    He has been average this year because Father Time has come early.
    In his Brownlow and runner up Brownlow years he was magnificent.
    Long live Bambi !!!!!!



    Good player not questioning that Det

    The year he won it Gaz missed 9 and Fyfe missed 5 he beat Fyfe by 2 and Gaz by 4 Fyfe was rubbed out that year , th wheat Fyfe won the medal Fyfe missed 4 games and was injured due to a Sam Mitchell knee if not injured Fyfe would have won by 10+ again don't won't to kill Bambi just saying the facts

    Here are the facts Dungy.
    Priddis scored more votes in his Brownlow year than any other player so that is why he won the medal.
    Ablett missed "x" amount of games because he has the pain threshold of a "tsetse fly"
    Fyfe missed games (the first suspension was an accidental head clash) but the second was there.
    Priddis spent his whole season in the middle under the ruckman feet, in the heat of the battle.
    Priddis may not be as talented as Fyfe or Ablett but he was great at his craft and with what he has at his disposal.
    To say he doesn't deserve a Brownlow because he isn't as talented as some is not really a valid statement.
    Because you are playing the "if Fyfe wasn't suspended" and If Ablett hadnt missed games etc.
    I will give you one.
    If Nic Nat would take the 10 marks per game and have 20 possessions per game, like everyone expects, along with his other assets, he would win the Brownlow every year ^:)^
    +1 -1
  • buffybuffy    277 posts
    Dunghole is so excited. markovino has said Priddis is average as well. Thats two who say so it must be right. Maybe we should get them on the couch next week with Gerard and they can tell all those so called experts what dickheads they are for ever suggesting that Priddis could play. Marko and Dunghole on the couch!! Can hardly wait.   Geez Dunghole dont ever pick on me again about spell check Read some of yours!!!
    +1 -1
  • dungydungy    9,278 posts
    edited July 2017
    buffy said:

    Dunghole is so excited. markovino has said Priddis is average as well. Thats two who say so it must be right. Maybe we should get them on the couch next week with Gerard and they can tell all those so called experts what dickheads they are for ever suggesting that Priddis could play. Marko and Dunghole on the couch!! Can hardly wait.   Geez Dunghole dont ever pick on me again about spell check Read some of yours!!!




    No probs champion love your feedback keep at it mate lol lol good to see you can read
    +1 -1
  • dungydungy    9,278 posts
    edited July 2017
    buffy said:

    Dunghole is so excited. markovino has said Priddis is average as well. Thats two who say so it must be right. Maybe we should get them on the couch next week with Gerard and they can tell all those so called experts what dickheads they are for ever suggesting that Priddis could play. Marko and Dunghole on the couch!! Can hardly wait.   Geez Dunghole dont ever pick on me again about spell check Read some of yours!!!

    So are you saying what i wrote was incorrect re Abblet and Fyfe how many games missed ? thats the facts buddy go back and check i can help if you need help im good like that 
    +1 -1
  • TheDivaTheDiva    13,248 posts
    That escalated quickly...

    +1 -1
Sign In or Register to comment.