G'day Punter!

In this Discussion

Who's Online

0 Members & 77 Non Members

2015 AFL Finals Series

Sport

Comments

  • AquanitaAquanita    566 posts
    edited September 2015
    oldhendo said:

    Am i the only person in WA hoping for a Hawks / Roos Grand Final?

    Probably today there would be few on your side but tomorrow is a new day. :))
  • thefalconthefalcon    20,505 posts
    all of Melbourne will be rooting for it, aqua...... [-O<
  • H-BOMBERH-BOMBER    10,567 posts
    Good luck tonight and tomorrow to all teams, Im hoping Freo and North can get through ;))

    Interest tonight, 10 EW on David Hale first goal at $17 and $5
  • thefalconthefalcon    20,505 posts
    who got the first goal?
  • tonytony    2,438 posts
    Walters

    octavius likes this post.

  • bradybrady    1,463 posts
    tony said:

    Walters

    The only highlight for Freo tonight
  • DarrbsDarrbs    410 posts
    Hawks just too good tonite. Four straight grand finals, what a team. Thought Spurr was huge for freo he cops a bit on here but great effort tonite. Maybe pavs last match if so what a career. Looks like Ross will never get one. Who knows. Big win for the Eagles tomorrow night and then a cracker of a gf next week.

    thefalcon likes this post.

  • thefalconthefalcon    20,505 posts
    i'll have my shegals voodoo doll out tomorrow night sticking pins in it.... X(
    carn the roos!!!!! :-bd

    rooboy, oldhendo likes this post.

  • paraleticparaletic    3,750 posts
    Feel sorry for Pav, goes to prove loyalty gets u nowhere.
  • SLIPPERGOLDENSLIPPERGOLDEN    8,513 posts
    Dockers finished on top of the league. Do not underestimate that achievement. In most other sporting competitions around the world that would make them champions but in the purely dollar driven event that is a grand final from the top 8 (unbelievable) they are now amongst the also rans.

    A true competition champion is the team that finishes on top after the home and away games. If you are allocating the champions after a one day knockout stage you might as well make it a knock out tournament from day one.

    squid69, thefalcon likes this post.

  • AndrewCarterAndrewCarter    2,171 posts
    edited September 2015
    Slipper I thought I'd seen and heard some nonsense but that seriously takes the cake :)
    It's the AFL not the EPL, nothing matters but the GF.
    Major league baseball world series champs, NBA its the playoffs winner, NHL Stanley Cup winner, NFL the superbowl, its the EPL that's out of step not the AFL.

    brady likes this post.

  • SLIPPERGOLDENSLIPPERGOLDEN    8,513 posts
    Wake up Andrew. The American competitions are due to East and West leagues.

    RIO likes this post.

  • SLIPPERGOLDENSLIPPERGOLDEN    8,513 posts
    edited September 2015
    Oh and it is dollar driven in the States as well.Do you really think a fair comp is decided by playoffs? No it isn't. Teams play each other home and away and the team with the most points wins. I don't care if it is the English Premier League or the Great Southern Under 12s Footy League.
  • G-MacG-Mac    1,678 posts
    I reckon this bloke will be enjoying some of Her Majesty's hospitality for a while.

    http://www.smh.com.au/afl/afl-news/afl-finals-2015-crowd-violence-mars-hawks-win-over-dockers-20150925-gjvet5.html
  • CarlosaCarlosa    1,287 posts

    Wake up Andrew. The American competitions are due to East and West leagues.

    Not sure about this Slip; get a bit sick of hearing this argument to be honest. Soccer is pretty much the only sport that does not have a finals series. Although, only in domestic leagues, the World Cup for example, is a finals series - the winner of the World Cup does not necessarily have the best record through the qualifying rounds. But no one doubts they are not the best team in the World, as they stand up when the heat really goes on, and that is what an elimination based finals series allows for. Another level of competition.

    Tennis tournaments - no luxury of playing everyone in the draw to work out who has the best record, you play who is served up, you win you progress.

    Even look at the Olympics, swimming and athletics....you have heats (regular season) and it isn't about winning those, it is about qualifying for the final, then the heat goes on and it is all left out there.

    Brisbane never finished on top of the ladder in their three-peat years, yet no one doubts they weren't the best team by a street - the regular season is about priming yourself for the next step up, the gruelling finals series!

    Good on Freo for winning the Minor Premiership, but it means squat.

    kane, brady, AndrewCarter likes this post.

  • PAULPAUL    2,665 posts
    edited October 2015
    Fremantle announce changes to squad for next season.

    Luke McPharlin (retired)
    Paul Duffield (retired)
    Ryan Crowley (delisted)
    Max Duffy (delisted)
    Jacob Ballard (delisted)
    Craig Moller (delisted)
    Josh Deluca (delisted) - to be redrafted as rookie

    http://m.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-premiership/ryan-crowley-axed-at-fremantle-dockers-while-paul-duffield-retires/story-e6frf3e3-1227562261305
  • dungydungy    9,278 posts
    PAUL said:

    Fremantle announce changes to squad for next season.

    Luke McPharlin (retired)
    Paul Duffield (retired)
    Ryan Crowley (delisted)
    Max Duffy (delisted)
    Jacob Ballard (delisted)
    Craig Moller (delisted)
    Josh Deluca (delisted) - to be redrafted as rookie

    http://m.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-premiership/ryan-crowley-axed-at-fremantle-dockers-while-paul-duffield-retires/story-e6frf3e3-1227562261305

    Add Bennell ,take Pav out and also add McCarthy and maybe Aaron Black then the window stays open a little longer i think
  • AquanitaAquanita    566 posts
    I think Rio may have got the daily double.

    No improvement in Fyfe and West Coast should trade Gaff if I recall.

    Brownlow and John Worsfold medalists!!! :))

    JayJay, darkshines, RIO likes this post.

  • DamienWyerDamienWyer    8,017 posts
    Ryan Crowley is a genuine loss for Fremantle. You only want guys who give you their all, Ryan was one of those.
  • JayJayJayJay    8,627 posts
    He's no Robinson Crusoe....I had Sydney as Premiers, West Coast missing the 8 (just) and Western Bulldogs getting the spoon. A nice "trifecta....only thing I got right was Mick being the first coach sacked.

    RIO likes this post.

  • AquanitaAquanita    566 posts

    Ryan Crowley is a genuine loss for Fremantle. You only want guys who give you their all, Ryan was one of those.


    Not as a 32 year old having been out of the game for that period of time plus the circumstances surrounding his suspension.

    The game would be well and truly past him now and those calling for his inclusion against Hawthorn have no understanding of the requirements of modern football.

    AndrewCarter likes this post.

  • LeglessLegless    5,108 posts
    IMHO he didn't have to get a touch - just have the aerobic fitness (which he should have had) to run with Mitchell and negate his influence.

    As it turned out Mitchell was BOG - 35 disposals and cut us up
  • AquanitaAquanita    566 posts
    Would have had more than that on any player lacking the match fitness that Crowley would have had. Would have been "Legless" pardon the pun at quarter time.

    oldhendo, AndrewCarter likes this post.

  • RIORIO    14,902 posts
    I still want Gaff traded by the way....its worse watching him play than anyone else in the league.

    As for Fyfe, he improved from second best to best...not much of a step up to tell the truth...Oh and i had the eagles fighting with about 3 other teams for 8th!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    :-O
  • JayJayJayJay    8,627 posts
    Aaron Sandilands wins Doig Medal...for the 2nd time....obviously very highly regarded by the club ...more so than some on here. Missing games like Fyfe did often knocks out obvious contenders. It's interesting to see the club's take on their players....Gaff over Priddis at West Coast, Gibson over Mitchell at Hawthorn. All the clubs have different systems and only Brisbane can come up with 4 equal club champions ...I remember when Leuenberger had a great year and didn't make top 8 and another time when Daniel Rich was a standout but didn't salute. Doesn't mean the umps got it wrong, just a different values based system. But for the much maligned Sandilands, a great result.

    RIO likes this post.

  • AndrewCarterAndrewCarter    2,171 posts
    edited October 2015
    Absolute indictment on the club's voting system that the Brownlow winner and the player who won virtually every other award going around and polled a near record number of Brownlow votes didn't win your clubs own medal, time for a revamp of the voting structure I would think. Obviously too much emphasis on missed games.
    Rio you're off your rocker mate, Gaff was clearly our best in the GF and by a considerable way and he was one of the very few players of ours who stood up all day and gave 100%. It was clearly his best ever game for the Eagles and illustrated exactly how far he has come, sometime you just have to give credit where credit is due and he was terrific.
  • AquanitaAquanita    566 posts
    Hard to disagree re Fyfe Andrew but the same could said for Priddis and Mitchell in their own club awards.

    It appears that the Clubs may apply different KPIs than the umpires, media and the players themselves.
  • AndrewCarterAndrewCarter    2,171 posts
    edited October 2015
    I wasn't surprised that Gaff won especially given his grand final performance and his performance in the biggest game of the year may well have got him home.
  • RIORIO    14,902 posts
    I'd still trade Gaff, he is weak and his disposal is poor....Glad his value is going up, but that only strengthens my resolve to have him gone.....Being the best eagle on the ground in the 2016 GF is not something you'd want to hang your reputation on
Sign In or Register to comment.